The Shadow of Certainty: Why We Fear the 'I Don't Know' in HR

-

In the world of talent management and organizational development, we are often expected to be the architects of certainty. We are hired to provide the "Right" framework, the "Correct" competency model, and the "Perfect" succession plan. We walk into rooms with decks full of data and graphs, hoping that the sheer volume of our research will silence the inherent messiness of human behavior.

But lately, I’ve been reflecting on the power of a phrase we rarely use in a boardroom: "I don’t know."

I remember sitting in a high-stakes meeting recently where the leadership was discussing a significant drop in morale within a specific department. They looked at engagement scores, they analyzed exit interview word clouds, and they compared salary benchmarks. Everyone had a theory. Everyone had a "fix."

When it was my turn to speak, I felt the familiar pressure to provide a polished, strategic answer. But as I looked at the data, I realized it didn't feel like a data problem. It felt like a human one.

"I don't know yet," I said. "Because the data tells us people are unhappy, but it doesn’t tell us what they are mourning."

There was a shift in the room. By admitting uncertainty, we stopped looking at the department as a "problem to be solved" and started looking at it as a "story to be understood." We moved from being analysts to being observers.

In HR, we often fear that "I don't know" makes us look less professional. We worry it undermines our authority as experts. But I’ve found that the opposite is true. When we stop pretending to have every answer, we create the psychological safety for others to be honest about their own confusion and vulnerability.

Authentic organizational development doesn't happen when we force people into rigid models of "how they should be." It happens when we are brave enough to sit in the gray areas with them. It happens when we admit that humans are not predictable algorithms, and that sometimes, the most strategic thing we can do is stop talking and start observing the "shadows" that the data doesn't reach.

Growth isn't found in the things we are certain about. It’s found in the questions we are finally willing to ask.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The HR Metrics We Miss

-
In most organizations, HR success is defined by what we can measure—engagement scores, attrition rates, time-to-fill, leadership pipeline health. These numbers matter. They tell a story. But they don’t tell the whole story. What they miss are the silent, deeply human moments that truly shape culture. The manager who checks in not just on performance but on well-being. The quiet resilience of an employee navigating a reorg. The way one empathetic conversation can turn disengagement into renewed ownership. Over years of consulting in talent and leadership, I’ve found that some of the most powerful shifts happen off the radar—between meetings, within feedback loops, during those rare pauses when someone chooses empathy over efficiency. Yes, we need competency models and robust frameworks. But they must serve the people they’re built for. A perfectly mapped leadership grid means nothing if it overlooks the very human context behind performance—stress, purpose, belonging. I once wor...
Read more

The Myth of Being “Always Available”

-
In many workplaces, responsiveness is celebrated. The manager who replies instantly, the employee who’s always reachable, the leader who never says no to a late-night call—these are often seen as signs of commitment. But somewhere along the way, “being available” has quietly become a measure of worth. When Responsiveness Replaces Effectiveness The problem is, being always available doesn’t necessarily mean being effective. In fact, it often does the opposite. Endless availability erodes focus. It creates an environment where urgent replaces important, and where depth of thought is sacrificed for speed of response. I’ve seen teams where employees hesitate to log off because their manager might send “just one more” message. The work gets done—but at the cost of energy, creativity, and eventually, trust. The Hidden Message Leaders Send When leaders are always available, they may think they’re modeling commitment. But the hidden message to their teams is: “You should be too.” Over t...
Read more

Behind the Scenes of HR Consulting

-
In HR consulting, especially at my level, most of the work doesn’t happen in the spotlight. It happens quietly, in the background, while everyone else is focused on the bigger conversations. I’ve realised that a lot of the real insight comes from simply being present in the room. You start noticing things that never make it into the formal agenda. A manager’s tired smile during an assessment. A team member who hesitates before speaking. The way a leader glances at their feedback report as if it holds something heavier than numbers. Once, during an assessment day, everything looked perfectly planned. Exercises were running smoothly, participants were engaged, and the schedule was on track. But during a short break, one participant sat by himself, tapping his pen in this restless pattern. When I asked if he needed anything, he said he was fine. Later, in his discussion, he opened up about feeling unsure in his new role. That small moment of noticing made the rest of his day make sense. T...
Read more